Some random thoughts to share, in the hope that writing them down will cease their noisy rattling in my head. Last night on television, a duck breeder who supplies supermarkets with a less-expensive version of the traditionally goose-produced foie gras said something so quintessentially French that I have to put it here. I hate to translate it because it just won’t have the same je ne sais quoi, but here goes:
“One must be democratic about foie gras in order to make it accessible to all French people – but not to the point where it lapses into mere paté.”
And speaking of democracy, who would not marvel at the medical egalitarianism of treating my 57-year-old malfunctioning knee with the same careful attention as, say, a 14-year-old’s anorexia nervosa? Every now and then, somebody raises the spectre of merit- or age-based medical treatment as a way of addressing the huge financial burden that threatens to sink public health care. Sorting out the smokers and the overeaters from the careful and consciously fit, and assigning priority to those who are in ill health through no fault of their own is more than a slippery slope – it’s a sheer drop into an abyss of calculated indifference. Replacing an octogenarian’s hip might not seem to have the same value for money as doing it for someone with, presumably, more time in front of them, but to my knowledge, age alone is not a determining factor for receiving treatment in any countries where public health care is a bedrock principle. One wonders how private medical insurers sleep at night.
If it’s not too late, slip ‘Being Wrong: Adventures in the Margin of Error” into your mate’s stocking this Christmas. Kathryn Schulz, ‘the sickeningly young, forbiddingly clever and vexingly wise’(1) journalist who writes brilliantly about the need to make mistakes has turned my smug view of other people’s wrongness into humble pie. It’s no exaggeration to say that this book is a relationship-saver, and maybe even a life-changer. Plus she’s got a damn good explanation for why some people can tell outrageous lies while the minor equivocations of others are writ large upon their face.
And still on the subject of books, I finally did something with the recommendation of my literate friend at Spit and Baling Wire to get ‘Reading Like a Writer’, by the deliciously-named Francine Prose, and have been glued to it for the past four nights. She starts with the importance of the single word, moving on to sentence structure, paragraphing, narration and who knows what else – I’ll let you know when I get there. The risk of taking a book like this to bed is that the excitement generated by the possibilities Ms. Prose’s analysis raises might evaporate by morning, although it could presumably be funnelled elsewhere in the interval. An absolute must if you’re serious about being a good writer – a ‘here’s how’ instead of a ‘what not to’ guide.
Cats are masters of the slippery slope, I have noticed this week - again. Our bedroom door has been kept shut since the day we were adopted by a large, unattractive tabby (a refugee from next door, something we only discovered after she’d been living with us for a year) in order to keep her hairiness off the bedcovers. Neither is she allowed on the new couch, the dining room table or my favourite Belgian’s computer keyboard, none of which she takes to heart. Last week, having left the bedroom door ajar, I found her on the bed, tucked up prettily with a paw over her nose and smack in the middle of a sunbeam and my favourite scarf. The hardest heart would soften at the sight. Since, the scarf placement has been adjusted to accommodate for the earth’s rotation around the sun, and the cat happily snoozes the mornings away.
I intend to submit an addendum to the Human Genome Project, having proof that diagnostic skills – or a lack thereof – is an inherited inability. When the middle child was an adolescent, I swore on a stack of hot water bottles that her abdominal pains were just Mother Nature’s way of reminding her that it’s tough to be female. When the surgeon said that it was good thing she hadn’t come to emergency any later than she did, I had to admit that acute appendicitis hadn’t even been on my radar. This same child has misdiagnosed herself any number of times, the latest being a fever she was sure was due to a common virus, but was in actual fact a subtle signal beamed to her brain by an infected blister on her foot, which she hadn’t really noticed was several sizes larger than the other one. (See merit-based medical treatment, above). And in the ‘Men and Women Inhabit Different Planets’ mould, her mother was ready to jump on the next plane to keep vigil at her bedside, while her father laughed uproariously at the prospect of the family’s first-ever amputee.
McDonald’s moved in down the road a while back. Like many here, I was disgusted by this display of globalization – Americanization, some think –in my own back yard and swore never to frequent the place, but my principles, rarely rock-solid, have crumbled like so many chocolate chip cookies. With a friend, I spent the whole of Tuesday afternoon there, taking advantage of free Wi-Fi and large tables to spread out notebooks and laptops and mutually support our literary efforts. There’s nothing like getting out of the house to focus the mind and besides MacDo, as it is referred to here, serves a more generous coffee than the French are generally willing to.
Ploughing up and down the abbreviated pool at the spa yesterday, I was thinking about territorial instincts, moderation, and that damn book that tells me how frequently wrong I am. The basin is only 15 metres (50ft) long, and just wide enough for three swimmers to do lengths, four if you abstain from the breast stroke. I arrived at 2:15, much later than my preferred slot of 12-1, when all French are sitting down for lunch, and found that I had competition for the space. Three middle-aged women were already in the dressing room – which is unisex, by the way, something I hadn’t realized the first time I stripped down in front of my locker – headed, quite properly, for the pre-pool shower. Their hairdos gave away the fact that they were not serious swimmers and would only swan around the pool, all arched necks and chit-chat. (Did you know that hair is cited most often as the reason women don’t exercise?). In less than a minute I was in my suit, cap and goggles in hand, hurrying across the wet floor, geisha-like, to be the first in the water. Never mind washing off all those pH-disturbing creams and perfumes that I never use anyway, I wasn’t going to let anybody encroach on MY lane.
One hundred tedious lengths, intolerable were it not for a rich inner life. Reviewing a long discussion I’d just had with a young woman whose capacity for straight talk has been a revelation to me, I realized that I’d been wrong on a number of counts. About what exactly doesn’t need to be revealed here, the point being that the beliefs that had informed my point of view were based on plain wrongness. It’s both freeing and humbling to find yourself so exposed, as long as you’re in safe company when it happens, which, as it happens, I think I was.
As for moderation, ‘in all things’ was the caboose on that particular train of thought. In consumption, acquisition, prevarication, procrastination, scepticism, yes - but not affection, appreciation or toleration (sic). However, moderation is not my default mode when it comes to eating banana bread or drinking coffee, and most unfortunately not when it comes to my expectations, particularly of others. This may be due to a family legend about the uncommon self-discipline of the Norwegian patriarch, a man who only needed to hear once that smoking had been proven to be bad for the lungs to give up, immediately and without apparent difficulty, a long-standing habit, and whose fondness for alcohol was despatched with equal ease when it threatened to become a problem. The story made a big impression on a little me, but in the way a blinkered horse has a limited perspective, his example became my excuse to be critical of others for their presumed weaknesses while remaining blind to the best of my own. Thank goodness for people who write books about the self-deception we practice on ourselves.
And now I’d like to wish everyone in this delightful world of writers and poets, artists and thinkers, comedians and cooks, a Christmas that reminds you of how well you are loved and appreciated. That there is much to be grateful for even though Canada has backed out of the Kyoto accord, a decision that may alter the landscape in more ways than one. After Durban, it might Chinese and Indian flags that bloom like algae on the backpacks of traveling Americans, since it’s certainly not cool to be Canadian anymore. I apologize to the world for my government’s shameful act and intend to make my own compensatory effort by starting a compost heap, at last.
Merry Christmas and Joyeux Noel!
(1) from a review in The Guardian
Woooo-hooooo! A cornucopia of delightful thoughts and informational bits and bites. Just the food for thought I needed on this dark grey afternoon. Thank-you Deb, C'est magnifique!
ReplyDeleteSuch a tasty post - as rich as that foie gras up there at the top. In the spirit of things, a disconnected tidbit or two:
ReplyDeleteIf you ever have the inclination, I have learned how to make felt out of cat hair. I'm willing to pass on the instructions.
Despite (and in some cases because of) what the politicians say, I am convinced the elderly will not be given appropriate or adequate care in the future. The only reason I'm glad my mother is gone now is that she received the pacemaker and stent that added years to her life without quarrel, and she died in peace and dignity. I'm not sure I'll have the same end, but I'm taking on weight loss, exercise and really good nutrition as a defense against the need for the medical establishment.
Of course, some of that will have to wait a week or two. There's that foie gras to consider, after all. Merry Christmas to you, and best wishes for a jubilant New Year!
I hope that you enjoy an excess of funnelling this yuletide, and never forget to "Blame Canada" :)
ReplyDeleteYou have filled my head, two times over at least. Every paragraph is worth a comment in reply--from pate to health care to conceding that McDonald's offers something we hate to acknowledge to eye-opening conversations with friends to books that help us articulate what we've been trying to define to edging out carefully-coiffed gaggles of ladies at the pool to casting our brains back over the course of a year, of a day, as a way of taking stock of where we are...
ReplyDeleteMost importantly, I shall lodge the idea that I can't believe you put expectations too heavily on others. Really? I can't see it. You seem so willing to find goodness in others that I can't believe you can be guilty of something like judgment.
Random follow-up question: the way you relate your life in France seems very matter of fact, as though being a Canadian expat in the So. of France is easy work. Is it so? Also, do tell about the new couch!
The best core workout will reinforce the center of action and motion in your entire physique. A lot of individuals consider very first of their arms, legs, back again, hips, and shoulders whenever they get started a fitness plan.
ReplyDeleteI'm going back and read this again and again. So much in one post! Really funny, and really thoughtful! Why, you are the Canadian/French Jon Stewart!
ReplyDeleteNow, about that unisex changing place before your swim...
Oh never mind, I'm gobbling it all up, and tip my hat to your indomitable spirit to make those laps at any cost.
Deb chatting is still Deb voicing thoughts, opinions, giving information and being generally interesting.
ReplyDeleteSmall talk a la (never mind about the accents) Deb is small talk worth having.
Is that book about 'how to write' really as good as you say? I have read (what else) that the best advice for the aspiring writer is to do rather than to 'learn' how to do.
I'm very glad that you have posted, you are always a treat.
Stimulating post Deborah, which proves once and for all that the answer IS 42!
ReplyDeleteFriko . . one urban legend holds that Sinclair Lewis, drunk as usual, addressed a Writing Class "Hands up all those here who want to be writers?" Every student raised a hand. "Then why the hell are you listening to me?" said Lewis "You should be at your desks writing." Then he fell down.
Also . . remember Stephen Spielberg's advice. "The road to Hell is paved with adverbs." (I'm highly suspicious of adjectives, too)
(Verification word is "arseigo" Why does blogger save the best ones for me?)
Dang, girl. That writing book lit a firecracker under your tail and with spectacular results! I'd already paused in my reading to complete my order for the Wrong book before I got to the--obviously hugely effective--second one. So now I have to trip back over to the online booksellers to put in another order and I blame you.
ReplyDeleteMerry Christmas and may the inspiration last. This was worth the wait.
my first thought on reading this was how much i'd like to meet both you and your cat . strong-minded ladies , both of you .
ReplyDeleteand then i realised that it would be rather intimidating .... someone who swims one hundred lengths regularly and can eat humble pie with grace and wit might be too awe-inspiring . i'll just continue to read each and every post with great pleasure ....
p.s. your neighbourhood mac'donalds caters to a much grander clientele than ours , i see . ours is at the more colourful end of town and , what with the daft young girls and their lover-boys , pimps , dealers and the odd random shoutey person weaving in and out , literary discussion might be difficult .
And - you left me with a great big smile at the end. From one Canadian-to-another..I so get this. Thanks for the book recommendations..they sound interesting. And - to you too - best wishes for a Merry merry..and sweet new year!
ReplyDeleteTo read you and Shoreacres in one day is enough to make me thankful I'M not the writer anyone looks up to! You are definitely worth every morsel, so thanks for writing your nibbles.
ReplyDeleteMerry Christmas and Joyeux Noel to you and yours!
Hahaha! Too much fun reading this post. I must say, not certain I would admit sitting in a McDonalds, but if it produced writing, so be it. I understand the jogging about to get a good spot in the pool. And I once sent my youngest into the first aid kit to get an old finger splint an older brother used. I did tell him where he could find the tape, but son of a gun if he didn't need surgery.
ReplyDeleteEnjoyed this ride with you. A joyful Noel to you also.
The foie gras issue is just another example of the "accessibility vs. quality" debate, which raised such discussions in the Man Booker Prize jury this year. It's hard isn't it to appeal to the masses and yet keeps the art intact. Francine Prose's book I have on my shelf, and my TBR list. Hopefully in the new year I can get a chance to read it. So you're spending Christmas in France, how wonderful! You'll miss the snow I know, albeit we're getting quite a warm Festival Season here in Calgary. To you and yours, Deborah, a very Merry Christmas and a bright New Year!
ReplyDeleteI'm beginning to think that I've become a erstwhile Egyptologist of The Blog--as in I arrive very very late to the discovery...
ReplyDeleteFantastic post! And not just because of your reference to a, what? literate friend? Ha! Ha! Ha! I'm delighted to hear that you are enjoying Francine's prose. Actually, she included the best thing I have ever encountered regarding friendship among her excepts for the book. You'll have to let me know when you stumble upon it.
Oh, those McDo bastards who make the environment so welcoming. You didn't even mention the wine accompaniment available to your burger.
If you want a serious mind fuck to the budding writer, check out Rick Moody's assertion that--in addition to Stephen King's edict that the road to hell is paved with adverbs--you shouldn't even be using adjectives. He actually had the culot to say that in an interview conducted by François Busnel in NYC as part of his "Les Carnets de François Busnel." Sauf le respect que je leur dois, that is such pompous BS.
As a reader, I also liked Malcolm Bradbury's "The Modern American Novel" (1983) & "The Modern British Novel" (1993). You might like them. I'll be looking for ‘Being Wrong: Adventures in the Margin of Error” by Ms Schulz.
Merry Christmas &, fortunately, I have no idea what to blame Canada for, so, I'm not holding you responsible.
Hardly a nibble...I'll pick two.
ReplyDeleteI think insurance companies have largely turned sharing the risk upside down on its head and somehow fool many into thinking that there is nothing wrong with the picture.
I used to be addicted to the McDonald's chocolate chip cookies...I have been clean for quite a few years now.
I just wanted to stop by and wish you a Merry Christmas, Deborah.
ReplyDeleteOkay, you convinced me: I went ahead and ordered "Being Wrong: Adventures in the Margin of Error".
ReplyDeleteAs for McDonald's, I found the chain provided welcome bathrooms when I was last in Paris in the late 90s.
So many interesting subjects in this post! One I can comment on is McDonald. What people in the US may not know is that McDonald has different menus in other countries. For example in France you can get wine. I had a great cup of tea in McDo in Cambridge, UK, and unusual local sweets in McDonald in Indonesia. I was reading that McDonald Europe was reorganized by a Frenchman a couple of years ago – in some restaurants they even can get different French cheese on their hamburgers. The French fries have less salt and the meat no sugar as in the US. Now McDonald Europe generates more revenues that in the US even though Europe has only a quarter of the outlets that are in the US. McDonald Europe has localized menus (can get fresh pasta in Rome.) Their kid areas have mini-gyms instead of play areas, etc. Here you get the same thing in all the US states. I am saying all this because many people don’t realize the difference. I knew there was a difference when I saw the McDonald off Boulevard St Michel on the left bank in Paris closed a few years ago because the staff was striking. They had large signs explaining their requests. So I like to go to McDonald when I am in foreign countries.
ReplyDeleteI hope you Christmas was peaceful and happy and that your New Year will be joyful.
Happy New Year to you and yours Debbie, from your other home city, Cowtown Calgary! And may 2012 bring you peace and joy!
ReplyDeleteI am so glad I came by, not really expecting you to have posted but just checking up. Love this. what a treat to have so many thoughts to mull upon, like a full box of Belgian chocolates. I might have to find the book on being wrong. I suspect I need help, particularly beautifully written help.
ReplyDeleteGosh you're a wonderful writer. I want your ability to string words together.
ReplyDeleteYour paragraph on age & health appropriate medical treatment is in discussion in the U.S. as well. Of course, it is the medical insurers trying to increase their bottom lines, stock value, etc. I sometimes think it would be okay to give lower rates to the fittest folk, I also know it's another step towards discrimination and we're already discriminated against what with pre-existing conditions, no-insurance lapses, etc.
The pool paragraph is funny. I would have done it too. I tried taking a pool aerobics class for my achy arthritic body. It was filled with old annoying women who wanted nothing more than to blag the entire class. I stuck it out for a month but kept encroaching on the space of other ladies who were unwilling to keep up and MOVE THEIR BOUYANT BODS to the instructor & music. They gave me looks like "who do you think you are?" It wasn't worth it. I've been pumping weights and doing cardio for the last 20 months but I miss swimming in a pool.
Happy New Year Deborah, from Deborah
A belated Merry Christmas to you and your family and a Happy New Year to all of you! :-) May 2012 bring more fine writing like the one to which you have got us used so far. Many thanks.
ReplyDeleteGreetings from London.
Really? Her name is Ms. Prose? Isn't that wonderful? I am going to tell my friend about this book. She longs for a book group of writers. Reading a book as a writer is brilliant.
ReplyDeleteThe paté quote is priceless. I hope your knee improves. I hope your Christmas was beautiful (one day Christmas in France for me, please), and I pray that your year ahead will be alive with all that you long for. You are a wonderful writer.
Reading anything you write is a treat. I think I may need that book. I've been working on that very thing with myself. Off to find it.
ReplyDeleteAnother reason to thank you for commenting on my blog. I'd been away for some time, so on my blog roll, or whatever, it did not say you had posted. I will have to order the book on writing. I would love to read a what to do book, instead of the what NOT to do.
ReplyDeleteAs for it not being cool to be Canadian... excuse me, but have you noticed what the USA is up to in how it treats the 99%? I shudder when I think of the assessing whether or not one patient DESERVES treatment over another, especially based on whether or not someone's life choices have been judged worthy by some group of actuarians. I shudder. I have friends who feel that they should not be treated before a 20-year-old. That their lives are essentially over at almost sixty.
Never mind. I could babble on and on. I won't. It's just that I want to say ONE post for you contains more food for rumination AND action that a month's worth of most of my entries. I am not slamming myself so much as marveling at how much you can articulate so entertainingly and cogently in one entry.
Here is to a wondrous new year, full of writing, reading, art, and all out joy.
I keeping thinking to see what's going on over here, then forget. Now, at long last, I have a sure-fire way of keeping up--putting you on my Good Reads blog roll! So here's to a new year, and you've given me inspiration for yet another new year's resolution: "One hundred tedious lengths, intolerable were it not for a rich inner life." As I once again this morning stared at my treadmill and opted for listening to music, reading, and poking around on my laptop from an easy chair, I fell upon your post and realized, that's it! I need a richer inner life. Happy New Year, belatedly, as is my way.
ReplyDeleteI think it's time I had another little nibble...
ReplyDeleteFinally getting around to reading this deliciousness...nummy-num. You are in much better shape than I am, my friend. I would be lucky to do ten lengths, but I certainly get that "rich inner life" thing. It gets me through many tedious efforts. :)
ReplyDelete